CURLEW

The photograph on this page is © Peter Beasley ARPS and the drawing is by Lizzy Hibbert © Upper Onny Wildlife Group

Curlews return from their winter quarters on coastal estuaries to their breeding grounds during March. Their far carrying, bubbling call, is perhaps the most evocative of all spring bird sounds, and Curlews are very conspicuous during this territorial display flight.

 

They are large birds, mainly grey – brown, with a white speckled breast. Their body is about the size of a Woodpigeon, with much longer legs, but their most noticeable feature is the thin down-curved bill, which adds another 10 -18 centimetres, around a quarter of their total length. They have a conspicuous white triangular rump in flight.

Curlews usually nest in rank vegetation, such as unimproved grassland and heather moorland, or in rushes or tussocks, on rough grazing or adjacent to pasture or arable crops. This provides thick cover for the sitting bird and eggs, and for chicks.  Curlews feed on open damp pasture and meadows, using their long bill to probe wet, boggy areas to find the invertebrates that they live on. They are ground nesting birds, so all-round visibility is important in avoiding predator attacks, and Curlews are only found in open landscapes.

The first clutch, almost always four eggs, may be laid from first half of April onwards, but usually around the end of April or beginning of May, with an interval of 1-2 days between each egg. Incubation usually takes 27–30 days. Chicks leave the nest immediately after hatching, and feed themselves, but they do not fly until 32–40 days later. They are well camouflaged, and very hard to find, but they are still vulnerable to predators until they can fly.

Display flights occur frequently up until mid June, but continue occasionally up until the second week in July. As later display flights are associated with nests that are still active, but most pairs have ceased displaying by the time their chicks would only be a couple of weeks old, this is probably an indication of a high rate of loss of nests and unfledged chicks.

Nationally, Curlew is in serious decline, and is on the Amber List of Birds of Conservation Concern 2002-2007.  The Birds of Wet Meadows Survey 2002 found a 38.9% decline since 1982.  The Repeat Upland Bird Survey 2002 revisited nine study areas that had previously been surveyed between 1980 and 1991, and also reviewed data from four other upland areas. It found an estimated decline of over 50%, with a 41% decline in only seven years between 1987 and 1994 at one site in North West Wales.

In the West Midlands , the Birds of Wet Meadows Survey found a 61.3% decline between 1982 and 2002.

In Shropshire , An Atlas of the Breeding Birds of Shropshire (1992) showed Curlew occurring in both the uplands, and lowland wet meadows, but suffering from a steady reduction in the area of optimum habitat in the lowlands. The County population was estimated at 700 pairs. Since then, the decline in the lowlands has continued. The Birds of Wet Meadows Survey covered 11 sites, mainly in the Severn Valley and the Wealdmoors north of Telford, and found a reduction from 25 pairs to 11 (a 56% decline).

In the uplands, breeding bird surveys on the Stiperstones and the Long Mynd have shown a catastrophic decline of Curlew in the last 10 years.

The Long Mynd Breeding Bird Project found 11-13 pairs in 1995, declining to 7-8 pairs in 1998, 3 pairs in 2002 and 2003, and only 2 pairs in 2004. Not surprisingly, there were very few confirmed breeding records, even for such a conspicuous bird, indicating very poor breeding success.

Five breeding pairs were recorded on the Stiperstones in 1995-96, but the species had apparently ceased breeding prior to 2000, and certainly none were found during Breeding Bird Surveys there in 2002 and 2004.

Curlews have also declined considerably in the Upper Onny area in recent times, and a survey in 2004 estimated the population at only 24 pairs in 122 square kilometres between the Long Mynd and the Welsh border. Breeding success of these remaining pairs appears to be low, and insufficient to halt, let alone reverse, the decline. The breeding density is also relatively low, and Curlews are found now only in areas of wet pasture, where emergent springs have enabled soft rushes to remain.

A comparison of the 2004 Survey Results with the relevant section of the distribution map in The Atlas (1992) shows a marked decline of the species locally. The Atlas map shows the evidence of breeding found in each Tetrad between 1985 and 1990 - confirmed breeding or probably breeding, or present or absent in the breeding season. The records from this 2004 Survey can be mapped in the same way.  The comparison between the two surveys is shown in Maps C and D on the previous page.  

It will be seen that, during The Atlas (1992) period, Curlew were recorded in every single one of the 30 Tetrads covered by the 2004 Survey, with confirmed or probable breeding in 28 of the 30 Tetrads.  In 2004, this species was breeding in only 20 Tetrads, and was not recorded at all in seven of them.

Nationally, the population decline is attributed primarily to agricultural intensification, leading to changes in the breeding habitat:

For example, studies elsewhere found one pair per square kilometre on dry pasture and arable land in Scotland, compared with 2.4 - 2.9 pairs per square kilometre on rough grazing in the same area; while densities on marginal farmland sites in Northern England declined from ten pairs per square kilometre to one pair per square kilometre as the proportion of improved grassland on the sites increased. Drainage and re-seeding means that even the Shropshire hills are now mainly relatively dry pasture.

In the Upper Onny survey, four pairs in a Tetrad was the maximum density recorded, and this occurred in only one instance. However, the territories of these pairs also included part of the adjacent Squares, so even the highest density found was somewhat less than one pair per square kilometre.

If a pair loses its first clutch, a replacement may be laid, 4 - 15 days after the loss. Thus Curlew nests and chicks are vulnerable to agricultural operations from early April to late July. Rolling of grassland was first noted in the Upper Onny survey area on 20 May, and cutting of silage on 24 May. Similar operations take place throughout the summer. Many pairs will still have eggs in the nest when this activity starts, and any hatched chicks tend to stay in deep cover, and therefore remain hidden in the grass while it is rolled or cut.

Curlews generally suffer from poor breeding success, but they are particularly vulnerable in the Shropshire Hills because intensive sheep grazing has reduced the available cover for nests and chicks. More importantly, predation has also played a part in the decline - the smaller number of Curlews, with the reduced amount of nesting cover, mean nests and chicks are ever more vulnerable to the increasing number of predators, particularly Corvids and foxes. The increased availability of carrion from dead sheep has almost certainly increased the numbers of these predators considerably. Though no counts have been made, Crows now breed at very high densities. For comparison, it is known that the County population of Raven, another potential but less numerous predator, has increased fivefold in the 13 years since The Atlas was published, as a result of increased availability of carrion. This food source will also have benefited all the other, more numerous, predators, to the detriment of Curlew.

It is not known whether the declines on the Stiperstones and Long Mynd are primarily due to high levels of predation of nests and chicks on those sites, or a migration of breeding pairs down onto the adjacent farmland, which might appear to be more suitable breeding habitat, but where breeding success will also be poor as a result of agricultural operations as well as predation. 

In short, there are many fewer places in Shropshire where Curlews can nest, and destruction or predation of nests and chicks means that insufficient young birds fledge to replace the older ones that die off.

However, help may be on the way.  The current agriculture subsidy scheme, which created the modern farming conditions which Curlew find intolerable, is being phased out.  The new system, announced by the Government’s Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs (Defra) on 3 March 2005 , includes an Environmental Stewardship Scheme which has options to pay farmers to manage their land to reverse the decline of many farmland birds, including Curlew.

Defra, the AONB Office, the National Trust, English Nature, and a whole range of other conservation organisations are working together to encourage landowners to take advantage of the new subsidy scheme, and farm for the benefit of Curlew and other bird species, not agricultural surpluses.

The Shropshire Ornithological Society is trying to locate all Curlew breeding sites, to provide advice to Defra and farmers on the sites that should benefit from the new subsidy scheme.  If you see Curlew anywhere, during the breeding season (mid – March to mid July), please submit a record to the County Recorder by e-mail or ring Leo Smith on 01588 638577. For more information on the submission of bird records click here.

back to previous page